subscribe: Posts | Comments

Undocumented Children and Statelessness

What does being ‘undocumented’ mean?

An undocumented person is unable to provide the documents necessary to prove that they are a citizen of a country. Even if a person is a fully eligible for citizenship of a state, they will be unable to access the benefits of being a citizen (such as the right to legally marry, or to own property), if they cannot provide the documents required to back up their claim to citizenship.[1] An undocumented person might find themselves at a high risk of statelessness if they lack the documentation to prove their nationality.

Since undocumented people cannot prove that they belong to any country, they cannot count on a government to protect them and meet their needs. The difficult situation they are in is intensified when it comes to undocumented children. Undocumented children do not legally exist, and are an extremely vulnerable population, defenseless against all sorts of exploitation and rights violations. They are, for all intents and purposes, invisible, because they only exist under the radar.

What is statelessness? How can being undocumented lead to being stateless?

The term ‘stateless person’ refers to “a person who is not considered as a national by any State under the operation of its law”.[3] The right to have a nationality is a basic human right identified by the United Nations. However, many people are denied this right – there are an estimated 12 million stateless people in the world today and 5 million are children.[4] Being denied citizenship of a state is often equivalent to being denied the ‘right to have rights’. Stateless people exist in a legislative gray area, where, paradoxically, they legally have no legal identity.[5]

When undocumented children cannot produce the documents to confirm that there is a link between them and a state, they are left at risk of not belonging to any state at all, and becoming stateless. Since they cannot prove where they were born or who they were born to due to their lack of documentation, they run the risk of not being recognized and provided for by any state, and thus becoming stateless. Some undocumented people may be considered ‘de facto’ stateless, as they would lack an effective, functional nationality with which to access the privileges of citizenship, even though they are legally entitled to one.


[1] E. Simperingham, “The International Protection of Stateless Individuals: A Call for Change” (LLB (Hons) diss., University of Auckland, 2003), http://www.refugee.org.nz/Comment/Michael.html (accessed February 20th, 2013).

[2] United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, “Convention on the Rights of the Child,” (Article #7), November 28, 1989, Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, http://www2.ohchr.org/english/law/crc.htm (accessed January 14, 2013).

[3] United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, “Convention Relating to the Status of Stateless Persons,” (Article #1.1), September 28, 1954, Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, http://www2.ohchr.org/english/law/stateless.htm (accessed February 13th, 2013).

[4] Open Society Foundations, “Stateless Children: Denied the Right to Have Rights,” Open Society Foundations, http://www.opensocietyfoundations.org/multimedia/stateless-children-denied-right-have-rights (accessed February 27, 2013).

[5] Asian-African Legal Consultative Organization (AALCO), “Summary Report of the Forty-Fifth Golden Jubilee Headquarters Session of the Asian-African Legal Consultative Organization,” (Article #6.23), Report of AALCO’s Forty-Fifth Session, 8 April 2006, AALCO, [http://www.aalco.int/18Summary%20Report%20in%20column%202006.pdf], Accessed 08 January 2013, 151-185.

 

See related posts below for more information

Report on the 5th International Assembly

by Sumithra V. Ananthan Last month we were invited by Salinlahi Alliance for Children’s Concerns to a workshop entitled “Children In the Midst of Corporate Globalization: Issues and Challenges.” Salinlahi is an alliance of organizations and institutions advocating for the rights and welfare of children in Philippines This workshop was part of...Read More »

The Rohingya Refugee Crisis

By Jeremy Wilson – Research Coordinator | Same Skies* In May 2015, hundreds of Rohingya asylum seekers found themselves stranded in the Bay of Bengal after being abandoned by people smugglers. A recent crackdown on people smuggling in Thailand had disrupted long established trafficking routes1. Consequently, smugglers started a new trend...Read More »

‘Stateless: Forgotten Children screening at Pisco Bar and Restaurant

By Natalie Varnham “An enjoyable yet thought-provoking evening for an important issue”  Thursday 20th August, Voice of the Children held a fundraising screening of their film ‘Stateless: Forgotten Children’. The film addresses the issues faced by stateless persons in Malaysia, and follows three individuals that encounter daily challenges caused by their current...Read More »

Stateless Children in Sabah

Photo Credit: Free Malaysia Today by Joti Kohli Statutory Obligations Towards the end of 2014 we witnessed intense discussion in the media on providing the stateless children in Sabah with birth certificates so that they can be entitled to primary education.  This issue is a controversial one and while there are some legitimate...Read More »

Legal Awareness Programme - Brainstorming Session with Children

YCK children identifying pictures with emotions by Joti Kohli As our friends and supporters you know VoC is working on a Legal Awareness programme for children.  We wrote about the successful session with a group of experts on developing the content for the programme and have now conducted a session with the children...Read More »

PUTERI'S STORY

This is a drawing by Puteri. In her own words: “This is my mother and this is my father. Mother wants to go walking. Father wants to go to work, but he drops me off here first. Mother is going to meet her boyfriend but Father won’t let her. I...Read More »

Older Entries »